Policy Update
Anamitra Sinha
Background
The H-1B visa program is one of the most critical pathways for high-skilled professionals to work in the United States. It serves as a cornerstone of the U.S. economy by facilitating the recruitment of foreign talent in specialty occupations such as technology, engineering, healthcare, and research. Since its inception under the Immigration Act of 1990, the program has played a pivotal role in addressing skill shortages, fostering innovation, and maintaining the U.S.’s competitive edge in global markets.
Indian nationals are the largest beneficiaries of the H-1B program, consistently accounting for over 70% of the annual visa allocations (USCIS, 2022). For many, the H-1B visa is not merely a work authorization but a gateway to long-term career opportunities and eventual permanent residency in the United States. The program also serves as a bridge for companies seeking to leverage global talent, particularly in industries where demand outstrips the supply of qualified domestic workers.
However, the H-1B visa program operates under a strict annual cap, limited to 85,000 visas—65,000 for general applicants and an additional 20,000 for individuals holding advanced degrees from U.S. institutions. This cap represents only 0.05% of the U.S. labour force, creating a significant bottleneck in meeting labour market demands (NFAP, 2022). The increasing volume of applications has resulted in a lottery-based selection system, introducing an element of uncertainty for both employers and applicants.
In recent years, the program has faced mounting scrutiny, with critics questioning its impact on domestic employment and wages. Simultaneously, there is growing concern about misuse of the system, particularly through the submission of multiple registrations for the same beneficiaries to improve selection chances. In response, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) proposed a rule in October 2023 to modify the selection process for the H-1B lottery. This rule aims to address inefficiencies by focusing on unique beneficiaries rather than individual registrations, thereby curbing the practice of multiple filings while ensuring a fairer distribution of opportunities.
The context of these reforms becomes even more significant against the backdrop of the 2024 U.S. presidential election, which is expected to shape the broader immigration policy landscape. With immigration remaining a divisive issue in American politics, the proposed changes to the H-1B program highlight the delicate balance policymakers must strike between economic priorities, labour market realities, and public sentiment. Add about recent election promise of trump
Functioning of H-1B Visa and Recent Reforms
The H-1B visa program, introduced under the Immigration Act of 1990, allows U.S. employers to temporarily hire foreign workers in specialty occupations requiring advanced knowledge and skills. An H-1B visa is initially valid for three years, with the possibility of a three-year extension. For many Indian professionals, the H-1B serves as a pathway to permanent residency, commonly referred to as a green card.
However, the demand for H-1B visas far exceeds the annual cap of 85,000, comprising 65,000 regular visas and 20,000 reserved for those with advanced U.S. degrees. The lottery-based selection process leaves many applicants in uncertainty. Moreover, the backlog for green cards disproportionately affects Indian nationals, with some waiting decades due to the per-country cap on employment-based green cards (Nandigama & Sheffner, 2021).
In recent years, U.S. immigration reforms have introduced challenges for H-1B applicants and holders. For instance, the Trump administration’s “Buy American and Hire American” executive order tightened eligibility criteria and increased scrutiny of applications, leading to higher rejection rates (Anderson, 2020). While the Biden administration has sought to adopt a more inclusive approach, challenges persist, such as fee hikes proposed in 2023 for H-1B visa petitions, which could disproportionately burden Indian applicants and small businesses reliant on foreign talent (USCIS, 2023).
Impact on Indian Diaspora and H-1B Visa Holders
For the Indian diaspora, these developments carry profound implications. H-1B visa holders often face prolonged green card backlogs due to country-specific caps, leaving many families in prolonged legal and financial uncertainty. Additionally, the financial and emotional burden of navigating the visa process can be immense, particularly for dependent spouses and children who are directly affected by policy changes.
As the 2024 H-1B lottery approaches, the proposed reforms represent a crucial juncture for U.S. immigration policy. They offer an opportunity to address systemic inefficiencies while ensuring the program continues to serve its dual purpose of supporting the U.S. economy and providing a pathway for skilled professionals worldwide, particularly from India, to contribute to and thrive in the United States.
- Economic Contributions and Job Market Dynamics
Indian H-1B visa holders significantly contribute to the U.S. economy. A 2022 report by the National Foundation for American Policy (NFAP) found that H-1B workers were vital for innovation, particularly in STEM fields, where the U.S. faces a skills gap. Indian nationals, often employed by tech giants like Google, Microsoft, and Amazon, help drive technological advancements and economic growth (NFAP, 2022).
However, critics argue that the program may suppress wages for American workers, a claim not substantiated by robust data. Studies reveal that H-1B workers typically earn comparable or higher wages than their American counterparts, highlighting their role in complementing the domestic workforce rather than displacing it (Peri et al., 2021).
- Family and Social Impact
The immigration backlog disproportionately impacts Indian families, with nearly 1.2 million individuals stuck in the employment-based green card queue, many of whom are Indian nationals (CATO Institute, 2023). This backlog leaves families in limbo, unable to make long-term decisions such as buying homes or investing in education. Moreover, the dependent spouses of H-1B holders, often on H-4 visas, face restrictions on employment, limiting their professional growth and financial independence.
- Mental Health and Uncertainty
The unpredictability of H-1B renewals and green card processing exacerbates stress among visa holders. Fear of losing legal status can lead to anxiety and depression, particularly for individuals with deep roots in the U.S. The on-going legal and policy uncertainties create an environment where highly skilled workers feel undervalued and insecure, prompting some to explore opportunities in other countries such as Canada or the UK, which offer more streamlined immigration pathways.
- Impact on U.S.-India Relations
Immigration reforms affecting Indian nationals on H-1B visas hold deeper implications for U.S.-India relations, given the two countries’ strategic partnership in technology, healthcare, defense, and economic initiatives. As the largest group of H-1B beneficiaries, Indian professionals play a crucial role in sustaining the U.S. tech industry. For instance, over 73% of H-1B visa holders in recent years have been Indian nationals, primarily working in IT and engineering sectors, often for American companies or Indian firms with a U.S. presence.
Restrictive H-1B policies, such as heightened scrutiny and fee hikes, could diminish the talent pipeline critical to U.S. tech competitiveness and innovation, leading some firms to shift operations to India or other nations. This “reverse brain drain” has the potential to weaken the collaborative U.S.-India projects and hinder the tech ecosystem that relies on skilled Indian professionals. For instance, technology initiatives like the Indo-U.S. Science and Technology Forum and the defense tech sharing under the U.S.-India Defense Technology and Trade Initiative could be compromised if mobility and talent-sharing are restricted.
From India’s perspective, restrictive policies affect family reunification and career stability for thousands of professionals, who may face decades-long waits for green cards. This uncertainty could also prompt Indian firms to prioritize domestic tech development, fostering a more self-sufficient talent ecosystem within India itself. In the long term, this shift could position India as a competitive hub for tech innovation, potentially leading American firms to engage more directly in the Indian market rather than bringing Indian talent to the U.S.
On the other hand, policies that support mobility, such as the recent easing of H-1B rejection rates under the Biden administration and initiatives to reduce green card backlogs, could bolster the strategic alliance. By facilitating a smoother pathway for Indian professionals, these policies would not only strengthen U.S.-India tech and defense partnerships but also reinforce the mutual economic benefits—boosting the U.S. economy while enhancing India’s global talent footprint.
Way Forward
A more balanced and equitable immigration system is essential to address the challenges faced by Indian H-1B visa holders while aligning with U.S. economic and strategic goals. Here are some recommendations:
- Increasing the H-1B Cap
Given the demand-supply mismatch, increasing the annual cap for H-1B visas could alleviate some pressures and enable U.S. employers to access the talent they need. Targeted reforms could prioritize sectors facing acute labor shortages, such as healthcare and technology. - Addressing the Green Card Backlog
Legislative efforts, such as the proposed Equal Access to Green Cards for Legal Employment (EAGLE) Act, aim to eliminate the per-country cap on employment-based green cards. Passing such reforms could reduce the backlog and ensure fairer access for Indian nationals. - Simplifying Application Processes
Streamlining the H-1B application process, reducing administrative burdens, and ensuring consistent adjudication standards can enhance transparency and predictability for applicants and employers. - Enhancing Work Authorization for Dependents
Expanding employment opportunities for H-4 visa holders, as initiated by the Obama administration, can empower dependent spouses and contribute to household financial stability. - Strengthening Bilateral Engagement
The U.S. and India should continue to collaborate on immigration issues through high-level dialogues and agreements that recognize the mutual benefits of skilled migration. For instance, India’s on-going negotiations for a U.S.-India mobility agreement underscore the importance of this issue in the bilateral agenda.
Conclusion
The evolving U.S. immigration landscape poses both challenges and opportunities for Indian H-1B visa holders. While reforms are essential to address systemic inefficiencies and labor market dynamics, they must balance economic imperatives with the human impact on immigrant families. By adopting inclusive and data-driven policies, the U.S. can continue to attract and retain global talent, reinforcing its position as a leader in innovation and economic growth.
References
- Anderson, S. (2020). The impact of Trump’s immigration policies on the U.S. economy. National Foundation for American Policy.
- CATO Institute. (2023). The employment-based green card backlog: An ongoing crisis.
- National Foundation for American Policy (NFAP). (2022). H-1B visas and the contributions of highly skilled workers to the U.S. economy.
- Nandigama, N., & Sheffner, S. (2021). Reforming the U.S. green card system: Challenges and solutions. Migration Policy Institute.
- Peri, G., Shih, K., & Sparber, C. (2021). H-1B visas and wages: Separating fact from fiction. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 35(3), 159-178.
- United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). (2022). H-1B program statistics.
- United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). (2023). Proposed fee increases and implications for visa applicants.
About the Contributor: Anamitra Sinha, Policy Research Intern at IMPRI Institute and Master’s student in Development, Policy Planning, and Practice at Tata Institute of Social Science, School of Rural Development, Tuljapur (Off-Campus).
Acknowledgment: This article was reviewed by IMPRI experts and other collaborators.
Read more at IMPRI:
Kudumbashree (1998): The Power of Self-Help Groups Transforming Lives at the Grassroots
